Reports from Planet Drum Staff (Spring 2001)
Click on map for larger version.
Amy Jewel worked in Ecuador during Spring, 2001. She sent two reports that follow up on the events set in motion with the Eco
Committee's proposals and subsequent Public Meetings in February.
Index to Amy's Reports
Report # 1 (February 26, 2001)
Report # 2 (March 13, 2001)
Amy Jewel, Field Assistant
Planet Drum Foundation
February 26, 2001
We presented the official Spanish version of the Ecological Plan to Dr.
Luis Mendoza, President of the Mayor's Commission on Tourism and the
Environment, on Tuesday, February 20th. This is the body that will take
the plan to the City Council for discussion and eventual approval, or
disapproval. "Nos vimos" (we shall see).
During our brief discussion of the plan, Dr. Mendoza stressed the
importance of educating children about ecological subjects. We learned
that he, like most persons in Bahia, has several other jobs. In addition
to also serving as Vice Mayor, he is a teacher at the Inter-American
Luis expressed how crucial it was for the city to continue promoting
awareness of composting and recycling with school children and
adolescents. As a result, I am preparing a proposal for a pilot composting
project at one of the local schools.
Although the ecological plan (see index
for complete text) would be fairly ambitious for any city, we had changed
the title and the scope of the plan to include all of Canton Sucre, not
only Bahia de Caraquez. This step was taken due to the legislative
structure within the Canton. We explained the situation to Dr. Mendoza,
who understood the necessity for making this adjustment. He believes that
the implementation of the plan will focus on Bahia de Caraquez anyway,
with eventual expansion of most projects and activities to the rest of
The substance of the plan is partly real already, partly possible, and
partly a dream. Some of the goals are certainly not fully attainable in
the next three and a half years of Mayor Leo's term, while some others
have actually been realized already. The overall plan serves as a good
blueprint of ideas for other municipalities that wish to commit to
ecological goals, and it is a good source of information to allow the
public to begin to understand and embrace ecological ideas. To this end, I
continue to publicize the plan through the local radio stations and
Other projects continue at a rapid pace. A local school teacher who
helped prepare the plaques for "The Forest in the Middle of the
Ruins" is assisting to complete clearing the pathways. We also
surveyed tentative locations to hang the new educational plaques along the
pathway. Major Medina, who is the commander of the National Police in
Bahia, has promised that some of his men would visit the park at least
once a week to check security. Ivan Aguirre, Director of the Hygiene
Department, is considering future regular maintenance of the park and
Michelle Viteri, the mayor's wife, provided me with a list of possible
sources of funding for ecological projects. Together we had prepared two
grant proposals for the British Embassy, and we are now planning to update
those proposals and send them to various other NGOs, governmental
agencies, and international agencies.
Peter Berg wrote a proposal to revegetate about 96 hectares of land
from the edge of Bahia de Caraquez through the adjoining suburb named
Leonidas Plaza, all the way to a point called Kilometro Ocho. Unlike the
revegetation project in Maria Auxiliadora, this land is entirely held by
private owners, and some type of negotiation needs to be undertaken for
revegetation work to proceed. Several options are possible, and an open
dialogue between the landowners and the municipality is needed. The Mayor
has asked that Planet Drum spearhead such a dialogue, and this will be one
of the tasks I'll tackle ... after Carnaval. (Stay tuned to the next
report for further developments as well as observations about Carnaval.)
Cultural note on time. Most people here have a different conception of
time than the inhabitants of the United States and other "developed"
countries. For example, a meeting at 4 PM can mean that someone arrives
anytime during the entire hour that follows. I have been left several
times waiting for 30 minutes or more for an appointment, and a few times
the person even failed to appear. Although this may be frustrating to
those of us who were raised in a culture of strict punctuality, there are
some surprisingly useful elements to this more relaxed conception of time.
Due to their laid-back attitude, people don't feel the need to divide
their day into tiny organized fragments in order to complete their various
It is not uncommon for a person to have two or three different jobs or
business enterprises, and people accomplish an extraordinary amount of
work. However, the tasks are completed in a flexible manner. In this
sense, the timing of some activities can actually be much more rapid than
it would be in the United States. There is also a lack of bureaucracy that
tends to speed up many processes.
A first-hand example: health care. Usually in the United States, I call a doctor's
office to make an appointment, and after navigating a confusing voice mail
message, and after being on hold for at least 15 minutes, I may be told
that no appointments are available for several weeks or even months!! At
which point I hang up the telephone disgustedly and search for another
doctor, but of course, only a doctor that may provide care under the terms
of my insurance plan.
When I caught a sinus infection last week, I went to the doctor's
office at 1 PM to make an appointment, and was told to return that same
day at five. The nurse did not even ask my name, much less my social
security number. I returned at 5, and in roughly a half hour, I saw the
doctor, explained my problem, and we immediately went to the lab for a
blood test. By 6:30, we had the results of the test, and a prescription
for the infection. By 7, I had visited a pharmacy and bought the needed
Other examples abound. Instead of needing about a week's notice to
schedule a meeting, as is common in the business world where I work in New
York, you need only about a day's notice, and sometimes less, to schedule
a meeting. Urgent tasks tend to be prioritized and completed when
necessary. Yet, the people do not rush around to their various jobs or
duties, but take their time to work in a relaxed, refreshing manner. As a
result, I have found the pace of life here overall to be calm and tranquil
while sufficiently efficient and rapid, at the same time.
Report # 2 — Last Days in Bahia
Amy Jewel, Field Assistant
Planet Drum Foundation
March 13, 2001
(Writing from Memphis, Tennessee)
"Well, we HAVE to do it."
These words were spoken more than once over the past few weeks by Patrick Rivadenerra, Director of the new Department for Tourism and the Environment, about accomplishing the objectives of his department. They were used yet again last week during a final meeting with Gabriella Chejtman as we discussed the next steps in the implementation of the Ecological Plan. Like Luis Mendoza, who is the Vice-Mayor of Canton Sucre, Patrick believes that the ecological education of children and adolescents should be given top
priority. He and Gabriella are going to write a detailed educational plan this week. Together we developed a timeline for this and all of the other objectives of the department.
Patrick's sense of urgency partially derives from his belief that the El Nino phenomenon will reoccur later this year. As evidence, he cited the heavy rains that began to fall last week, causing severe flooding in several areas near Bahia de Caraquez. Not everyone is so sure that El Nino will occur later this year, but almost everyone in Bahia (and in other parts of Ecuador) agrees that the weather patterns are no longer predictable. Indeed, I found it strange that there were very few heavy rainstorms during the two months I lived in Bahia, which was supposedly the rainy season. The city actually suffered from a water shortage for over a month while I was there!
Patrick is not the only one that has a sense of obligation as well as a fervor to transform Bahia de Caraquez into an eco-city. Two of my final hours in Bahia de Caraquez were spent with Rosie, a reporter with one of the local newspapers. She had agreed to meet me early on Sunday morning to visit "The Forest in the Midst of the Ruins" so that she could write a newspaper story about the park featuring the fact that we had just placed new educational plaques along the main pathway of the park. It soon became clear that Rosie's interests went beyond the park and the plaques. She asked, "Why do you think living in an ecological manner is important?" (a complex enough question to answer concisely in English, much less in my broken Spanish). The full realization of an eco-city may still be a dream, but it is one that is appealing to more of the citizens of Bahia de Caraquez.
Vladir Villagran is going to start a pilot composting project at his Genesis School (see
"Links"), when classes resume next month. Instead of building a compost bin, which would be costly due to the price of wood, he is going to take the suggestion of a friend and attempt to dig a compost pit in the ground. He will report on his experience with other schools and institutions that may wish to start composting on-site.
I provided a copy of the Ecological Plan to another reporter, and was interviewed about my role in its creation and
publicizing. Two grant proposals were revised, and I am now waiting to hear back from various organizations that may be interested in funding the proposals.
Eduardo "Cheo", a local school teacher who assisted in clearing paths in the park and posting plaques, wrote a proposed plan for the maintenance and continued development of "The Forest in the Midst of the Ruins."
Many possibilities exist for future projects. During a visit on my last night in Bahia, Flor Maria Duenas spoke passionately about her dream, which is to attack the problem of sewage in Bahia de Caraquez, and also in the Fanca district of Leonidas Plaza, a neighboring suburb of Bahia. Gabriella Chejtman would like to coordinate a volunteer program for environmental professionals, with the ultimate goal of performing environmental impact assessments to relocate the municipal landfill to a more suitable location. In August, Peter Berg will return to Bahia, and may be working with a specialist in alternative energy to explore the possibility of creating a demonstration site that incorporates alternative energy systems into the typical local architectural style.
Cultural note on Carnaval
The celebration before the beginning of Lent is one of the most important holidays of the year in Ecuador. Ever since my arrival in mid-January, I found that most local residents described the life in Bahia as "tranquil." Yet, there was always an exception: "Wait until you see
The mayor and Jacob Santos of the Bahia Bed and Breakfast Inn, seemed ambivalent about Carnaval. They spoke of
a large influx of tourists (obviously favorable for those involved in the tourist industry in Bahia) but complained about crowded beaches and dirty streets. Other residents seemed to look forward to the arrival of the tourists because of the more active atmosphere that the crowds would generate.
In the two weeks leading up to Carnaval, the city began to make various preparations. There were meetings about safety and
clean-ups. A detailed schedule of events was published in local and national papers, along with traffic advisories and other reminders, such as a schedule of tides for those planning to visit the beaches. New trash baskets were constructed, painted and placed throughout downtown. Overall, there was a sense of heightened activity and anticipation throughout town. One of the most interesting sights was the preparation for a fishing festival to be held in one of the neighboring villages. Several large, whimsical,
papier-maché fish and ocean creatures were loaded into a municipal dump truck to be transported to the site of the festival. This truck was a standard heavy-duty vehicle, built to move construction materials or other large objects over the roads of Ecuador, which are not always smooth, and are certainly not always predictable. To see this truck filled with delicate smiling sea creatures seemed to be a total reversal of "business as normal."
And perhaps that is an appropriate description of Carnaval: a reversal of the norm. One of the most widespread customs associated with Carnaval throughout Ecuador is the practice of throwing water or water balloons on passers-by. Anyone may be a possible target, from children to teenagers to adults, and even figures of authority.
In other ways, Carnaval seemed more like an exaggeration of the norm. Certain additions were novel, such as an outdoor screen near the small skating rink by the Malecon, used for the projection of music videos and other short video clips. There was also a small parade for the contestants in the local beauty pageant, but this was a minor event, and the streets were not lined for the occasion. The usual one or two hamburger vendors that appear every Friday and Saturday night multiplied to include stands selling snacks, sodas, and beer, some of which were operated right out of local residents' homes. Typical Friday and Saturday daytime crowds on the beach, and nighttime crowds in the streets and on the Malecon, swelled to congested levels. On the whole, Carnaval was simply a continuation of the peaceful but playful atmosphere that normally permeates Bahia.