9/30/26 Paul Cienfuegos
In recent decades, I have not participated much in the bioregional events across the US, although I have continued to actively follow the movement here and there. I was very active in the 1980s, attending two bioregional congresses in Cascadia and the NABC 3 in Squamish, BC, Canada, all of which I found to be tremendously exciting, visionary, and deeply impressive events.
Bioregionalism as a concept, as a political and ecological and spiritual vision, has enthralled me ever since the 1980s, and “bioregionalist” is one of my self-descriptors that I have used ever since. It was with this excitement about this movement that I attended the recent TIBC 11 near Vernonia, OR.
Months before the actual event, I found myself already becoming somewhat skeptical of what was being planned, for three reasons:
1) On July 8th, and again on July 26th, I wrote to the TIBC organizers with a detailed proposal for a specific relevant contribution that I wanted to offer at the Congress. I received no reply to my first email, and a minimal reply to my repeat email, which read in full…
“We will send information in an email soon about how to propose a session.
TIBC team”
Here is the email I sent twice:
“Greetings!
I’m one of the (now) elders who were once VERY active in the early bioregional movement in Cascadia in the late 1970’s and 80’s, when I was still a college student at The Evergreen State College in Olympia, WA. In fact, we hosted a number of those early Cascadia Bioregional gatherings on campus.
I am now 68, and have spent my entire lifetime as a grassroots community organizer, workshop leader, public speaker and author, most recently spending the past 28 years as a leader in the Community Rights movement, that has helped more than 200 communities in a dozen states to pass locally-enforceable laws to reign in large corporations’ so-called constitutional “rights”, and banning harmful (but legal) corporate activities, such as mining, factory farming, fracking, etc. (Check out my social movement bio HERE.)
I’m also the author of a book related to that work titled, How Dare We? Courageous Practices to Reclaim Our Power as Citizens. I have an entire chapter about watershed-based governance, titled, ‘Protecting the right of our rivers to exist, flourish and evolve by dismantling corporate rule, watershed by watershed’.
I would very much like to lead a workshop on this topic, and/or participate in a related panel. Can you assist me in finding out how to apply to do so?
And I would also like to find out what I need to do to sell my book at the Congress. Happy to just leave it on a table and trust folks to pay for it on their own.
Thank you so much for your assistance,
Paul Cienfuegos
Portland, OR
503-506-8333
PS. I signed up for your email updates many months ago, and have not received a single email from you since. Please ensure that I’m on your list. Thank you!”
I never received a further response, other than the generic email sent on August 3.
2) As someone who has followed developments in the bioregional movement for decades since my active involvement in the 1980s, I was frankly shocked to see VERY few names of our visionary thinkers / leaders / elders listed in the online program, which DID list many guest presenters.
3) Continent-wide congresses have consistently been run on a sliding scale that acknowledges that attendees come from very diverse class backgrounds, and thus many people cannot pay substantial fees to attend. And yet this event was charging a LOT of money to attend. No sliding scale. And even people who should have been our most honored attendees, such as Judy Goldhaft — Peter Berg’s long-time partner at Planet Drum — was denied a waiver of fees for 2 days’ attendance!
These three examples should tell you all you need to know about the serious dysfunction of the organizing group and how it was making decisions in advance of their event.
But I am barely scratching the surface thus far, of the utter catastrophe that unfolded day by day at this event. So much went wrong that I am going to urge the larger bioregional movement to DE-CERTIFY TIBC 11 as a Congress, and rename it as simply a “Gathering” or “Conference”. That’s how bad this event turned out to be in my opinion. So from this point forward, I will be referring to this event as a Conference.
The remainder of this statement is a list of all of the things that went wrong at the event, many if not most of this list could have been entirely avoided if the organizing group had had the necessary skills and focused attention to detail that is always necessary for this scale of events. ….
•• Upon arrival at the event, and having my first look at the actual daily schedule, I immediately noticed a serious problem. Most of the sessions and meals started at the exact same minute that the previous sessions ended. No transition time. Lunches were 60 minutes, with the previous session ending the very minute that lunch began and the next session starting the very minute that lunch ended. ANYONE with conference agenda building experience knows that this is a disaster waiting to happen. That it will become a certainty that events will have to be repeatedly rescheduled or canceled, as everything will run late hour after hour.
And of course this is exactly what happened every single day. The organizers were forced to change the schedule constantly. One of the most egregious examples was the presentation by two women from Mexico, who first had their session postponed because of what unfolded at the previous session. Then postponed again. Then they were told it was entirely canceled! The pushback from many attendees was severe enough that it was finally added back onto the schedule on the very last day, and turned out to be one of the best sessions of the entire conference.
Report-backs from the various bioregions SHOULD have been, and normally WERE, a central feature of these congresses. Sadly, not this time, as we learned little about what the various bioregions were up to.
And in fact, these bioregion-based groups were supposed to themselves meet numerous times on the conference schedule, but ultimately only met once, on the final full day, because the conference agenda was so screwed up.
The same experience was had by the small card-deck based groups, that also only got to meet once, on the final full day. Somehow the organizers thought that the card-deck groups could also meet over meals in the dining room, but the acoustics there made such meetings impossible. So I literally didn’t even MEET my Serviceberry group until the final morning, and we liked each other so much that we decided to meet immediately again over lunch at an outdoor picnic table, and have since linked up online for continuing community-building!
In general, folks had to race from one thing to the next, with no breaks built into the agenda anywhere. In response, many people just voted with their feet, and began to skip more and more sessions. All of the bioregional gatherings that I have attended have been spacious in their design. Informal time, musical time, campfire time. Community building time! None of this was built into the schedule. So the energy for five days was frenetic instead of spacious. A HUGE mistake by those who designed the conference schedule.
•• Another entirely avoidable scheduling disaster took place at the official opening of the conference, after breakfast on our first morning together. We were informed that we would be welcomed by members of the “Intertribal Leadership Council” and other indigenous peoples in attendance. That when we heard them coming up the path, with their drumming and singing, that we were to stand and be silent as a show of our respect. Unfortunately, they didn’t arrive for almost an hour, so hundreds of us just sat there waiting patiently. This is how we all spent the first HOUR of our formal time together! The organizers could have made good use of this time, but instead it was entirely wasted.
And once the indigenous people finally arrived, they took up sufficient time to push the next session back, as there was no acknowledgement from the organizers that this session would need to be somewhat shortened. And to make matters worse, a number of the indigenous men used their time to verbally insult and attack the mostly white attendees, classifying all of us as bad people. Guy was the primary accuser, and he ultimately alienated many of us from interacting with him for the rest of the conference. And I heard a number of reports from white folks who were further alienated when they simply tried to greet him afterwards.
Tragically, the conference organizers had never vetted the level of functionality of Guy or others prior to giving them a significant role in the welcoming ceremony. I absolutely get it that indigenous folks have a LOT of totally justified anger at white folks for what their people have endured for centuries in North America. But that still does not mean that a heavily traumatized indigenous man who has clearly NOT done his own necessary healing work should be chosen as one of the welcomers, to be actively interacting at a conference that’s mostly comprised of white folks.
And I’m also not convinced that the “Intertribal Leadership Council” was an actual real body of folks who knew each other, had some history of working together, etc. It felt much more like it had been thrown together at the last minute and given an impressive group title.
This is all in stark contrast to how the NABC 3 was organized in British Columbia, where the organizers group was made up of folks, both Native and non-Native, who had known each other and worked together in community, in place, for years already. Trust had been established in advance. The total opposite was what took place at this conference. There was NO local indigenous representation from the local area. Which is another reason why I urge the larger bioregional community to DE-CERTIFY this event and rename it a Conference or Gathering, not a Congress.
•• Another scheduling fiasco took place mid-conference, when just ten minutes prior to the morning full-group session in the big white tent, we were all urged to instead attend a ribbon ceremony led by indigenous participants. It went on for at least 30 or 40 minutes, which then made the already scheduled event much delayed, bumping the event that followed it, which was either then cancelled or rescheduled. I no longer recall.
Would it have been so difficult for the organizing team to have worked more closely with the indigenous participants, so that their offerings were actually ON THE SCHEDULE?! These sorts of agenda fiascos happened constantly. Which then naturally caused all of us to feel more jaggedy, anxious, off-balance, irritated, rushed. The exact opposite of what this event should have been.
It got so bad that I kept noticing that the conversations around me each day were full of frustration about the conference, rather than excitement about our work together.
•• Some further comments about how Judy Goldhaft was treated, and why she chose to not attend this event:
Judy and her long-time partner Peter Berg co-founded Planet Drum many decades ago. They were among THE primary founders of the entire bioregional movement of North America. Peter Berg passed many years ago, but Judy has remained a steadfast leader of Planet Drum. She is now an elder.
Judy didn’t have the money to pay the high fee for this conference. She asked to attend two days to meet and chat with people and was turned down! She offered that Planet Drum be listed as an organizational co-sponsor in exchange for them doing substantial publicity / outreach for this conference. She never received a proper response to that offer. She offered to bring a substantial selection of Planet Drum resources for display and to give away at the conference but was told there was no place for tabling! She then offered to send hundreds of large colored postcards about Planet Drum to the organizers, so they could put one in each registration packet. They agreed to do so but did NOT follow through on their agreement. So that very tall stack of postcards sat on the tiny literature table the whole week, with very few folks seemingly even knowing the significance of this org’s decades of service to the bioregional movement.
Judy also suggested to a significant bioregional leader in France, who would have had to spend a lot of money to fly to Oregon, that he apply for a scholarship. His request was also turned down.
Judy tells me that Brandon spent much of a day in the Planet Drum office in San Francisco, learning about their incredible decades of work, and yet still treated Judy as an insignificant player in this movement, in the awful way she was treated by the organizing team.
Another core founder of this entire movement, David Haenke, had planned to attend the conference, but wasn’t well enough at the last minute to fly to Oregon. But given his significance, similar to Judy’s, why was there not a scheduled event for him to lead? And even in absentia, could we have not had a session via zoom, where he shared his long history as a visionary elder in this movement. Same question re Judy. (I was told only today that there indeed WAS a zoom session with David Haenke, but that it was not publicly announced, so most of us missed it!)
I really got the feeling throughout the conference that the organizing group was purposefully minimizing those folks who were our elders. They were made invisible, irrelevant. I say “purposefully” because Brandon and Karie, and possibly others in the organizing team, have studied our bioregional movement’s proud history for years now, so they DID KNOW about these significant elders. Why was this history nowhere to be found in a five-day agenda? Especially given that there has not been a continent-wide congress in 17 years, so there are so many newcomers to this movement who knew nothing of this history, and needed to be welcomed into our truly breathtaking 40+ years movement with proper historical perspective.
•• Related directly to the formal offer I made months in advance to the organizing team to lead a session or join a panel, which was never properly responded to, I approached organizer Karie Crisp the first evening, to let her know that I had significant background as a community organizer and educator in watershed based governance, through my decades of work in the Community Rights movement, and that I had offered to lead a related session at the conference. And that I would be a perfect presenter for their session titled “Bioregions & Earth Law: Reimagining Law & Governance for a Living World”. All she was willing to offer was that I could speak from the audience for a brief moment at that session. So I attended the session, where she facilitated three indigenous women, one of whom was a law professor in Oregon.
The professor was asked a question about the history of the Rights of Nature movement, and she got the history entirely wrong, claiming that it had started in 2022 in South America. In reality, it started decades earlier, first in rural Pennsylvania and only then moving to Ecuador and Bolivia and many other countries, still way earlier than 2022. I had real expertise on this topic but my offering was entirely ignored.
This experience I had was repeated by many folks I talked with at the conference, many of whom had also written to the organizers, months in advance, as I had, offering specific expertise. Every one of them got no response!
•• Topic Circles or “participant-proposed sessions”!
In August, we were all sent emails encouraging us to offer sessions during the conference. It was explained that everyone online would then vote to choose the sessions of most interest to participants, and those sessions would appear on the actual program schedule. This is not at all what unfolded. Excuse my language, but this ended up as one of the biggest cluster-fck portions of the conference.