October 31th, 2026
Thank you for this critique. I remember well everyone who contributed their thoughts, and have been hoping to hear from some of the elders of the bioregional congresses I attended. I was at the congresses that took place on Lake Michigan, in British Columbia, and the Gulf of Maine. My work was in the economics committee and my books, Economics as if the Earth Really Mattered, and Invested in the Common Good, were published by the bioregional publisher at that time, New Society Publishers. In fact, I met them at the first congress I attended when David came to me and told me they were going to publish my book. A book I had no idea I was going to write yet. Such a gift, in fact!
To me, the congresses were full of magic and connections. Both with people, many of whom felt like long soul friends the moment we looked into each others’ eyes, and place. Every place the congresses were held, that I attended, were sacred, homes to Earth elders—trees, waters, minerals . . . deep energies. And All Species, David Abram—and also with huge smiles, Milo Guthrie. All Species in particular was and still is all the decades later, a huge reality in my life and one of the most important ways of being/relating that I continue to share in my ongoing work and writing.
I wanted to attend the virtual meeting but was not at the Cascadia event. I tried to connect with the organizers as soon as I learned there would be another congress after so many years but no one got back to me. I didn’t think I’d be able to be there, but I did have some hope until I learned how expensive it would be, on top of air fare . . . combined with how things are now . . . I decided it wasn’t meant for me to go. But my thoughts were there and I had hoped to hear glowing reports, and maybe even a revived movement I could be a part of, still, expanded and growing. I had also hoped (actually I assumed because I remember the values of the congresses and those of us who were involved, our intentions, our ways of relating to each other and Earth) there would be a circle of elders and maybe even a zoom to bring in those of us who could not be there but our hearts were there. I looked forward to learning how the new generations who put so much into organizing the event both grew and transformed who we were into today, while also honoring the past.
So the reports I heard from it were deeply troubling to me, and what seemed to me the lack of understanding of All Species, the meaning of “Welcome Home”, and a few of the other things that happened, hurt my heart. I well remember some uncomfortable times at the congresses I attended. There were disagreements, feelings were hurt, it wasn’t always perfect. . . . I also remember how carefully these were handled. I remember also, plenty of space to BE with the place we were inhabiting for a time. And the evening events, and daily rehearsals were so important to everyone who was there. Even those of us who were just the attendees in the evening, like me. My work was the economic committee so that’s where my energy went. The community we created together over the course of the week, seemed to me to be the point, not a byproduct. I met some of the most important people in my life at the congresses, and seeing each other every couple of years was so important to keeping my focus and energy high for the work I was doing at that time.
One of the criticisms I read of bioregionalism on the other platform I think it was, by someone who attended the recent event, was they expected there to be more hands on strategy, teaching how to do stuff, etc. What I remember is the congresses were times when those of us with projects in our own bioregions came together to share, learn from each other, support each other. There were workshops through out the event on all aspects of projects from permaculture to economics to land trusts . . . all kinds of hands on stuff. Many of us, like me, were active in our own bioregions in many ways and on every level. I lived in Vermont at that time and one of the main commitments of my organization, Catalyst, was to integrate bioregional awareness and values into everything we did.
I’m 74 now and living in NY. I hope for continued dialog. Listening and sharing, to move this most important work forward. Not as a revamped, newly minted version of bioregional, but as a rich, historied, movement that is a totally relevant, alive and vibrant, synergistic, life force. Because that’s what we need right now. We being the whole Earth community. All Species!