TIBC thoughts

My own reflections are below. I think Voice of the Turtle did an amazing job and VERY accurately captured what happened during the continental congress. They went above and beyond; to me they were THE most functional and one of the best parts of the congress, no question. The reflections I say below are solely my personal opinions, rather than filling in gaps in what was reported.

I think many reading this will disagree with my opinions. During the congress I spent a lot of time bouncing around and talking to as many people as I could to get their thoughts (especially new folks). Please understand that many of the views I express below, as painful as they may be to read, are shared by many attendees I talked to. Although many of the below thoughts are negative, I must emphasize I have hope; hope that a better, future continental congress is possible and within reach:

Overview

  • The congress generally was in my view a failure. It did not accomplish in my view most of it’s priority goals, nor was very functional. Many of us are taught to fear the concept of failure. I think there will be attempts to reframe or minimize this failure. I urge folks NOT to do this, but instead face this head on. At the very least, even if you don’t see this congress as a failure, please understand that me and some groups of other attendees do.
  • The congress was mostly composed of folks new to continental congresses and to an extent bioregionalism. I think the failure of the congress left a bad enough taste in many folks mouths. There’s potential that some attendees will have no interest in future continental congresses and will splinter, focusing on their more narrow areas. Some attendees may have been turned off bioregionalism in general.
  • The passion and talent of the attendees DID result in some meaningful connections + drive amongst some new folks to help with a future congress. I urge folks to cultivate these connections, to help create a 12th continental congress + create more bioregional activity in your given region.
  • Unfortunately I don’t think this congress will lead to creation of new centers of bioregionalism across the US, let alone the Canada/Mexico/other parts of continent. This is because majority of attendees were NOT from across the continent, as was the case (to my knowledge) in most previous congresses. Rather, a large majority of attendees were in fact from Cascadia area. As a result, this congress may assist Cascadia area folks in deepening existing activity in Cascadia. However I don’t see congress helping bioregional groups that are struggling to survive + recruit new active members, like the Kansas Area Watershed Council I’m a part of. I also don’t think the congress will revive groups from the past, who’ve been inactive for years. That being I think there’s consensus that it’s better to create new bioregional groups at this point, so ideas regarding inactive groups may be moot.
  • During the congress a controversy and rupture occurred. This controversy expertly reported on, in the later issues of Voice of the Turtle. I won’t summarize it here I encourage folks to read it instead, I’ve attached the issue which summarizes most of it. The controversy consumed most of the potential time, which could’ve been used for bioregional toolkit creation or meaningful inter/intra-bioregional connections. The controversy was at least somewhat resolved in my view. This resulted in a more positive very end of the congress and prevented a complete splintering. Much love and respect to all who helped create that outcome, in spite of countervailing forces.
  • A huge amount of $$ which could have lowered the cost of conference tickets for all, was wasted via work-trade discounts for some. I say this as someone who had a half-work trade discount. Many work-trade folks were given only loose direction for what to do (some weren’t given any direction) and there was no accountability metted out to work-trade attendees who shirked their duties.
  • As noted above, the controversy + other bad stuff resulted in very few opportunities for connection; compared to what could’ve been. I observed that attendees absolutely loved whatever little connection came though; like folks who’d been stuck in the desert and found an oasis. I observed folks trying to make up for lost time ANY time there was a connection. There was shared frustration between many attendees and this built to crisis levels over the course of the congress. This frustration though may have led to some manner of unexpected unity between many attendees. While the deep problems of the congress led to FAR fewer connections/progress than it could have generated, the deepened connections which did occur may have been deepened by the shared unity of frustration. I saw many new congress attendees say that event couldn’t have happened any other way. I very much disagree with philosophical viewpoints like this, BUT I can’t deny many attendees felt this way. I hope those views and connections can be leveraged to create a future congress and more of a transfer of knowledge from older, more experienced organizers; we’ll see.

What were underlying Causes of Failure?

4 factors I think were the reason this congress was an overall failure. I list a potential solution under each factor. The potential solutions I list are simply me thinking off the top of my head. I’m think multiple future meetings between interested folks could come up with better solutions than the ones I’ve quickly developed here:

  1. An overstretched core organizing team, who’s processes did NOT allow additional organizers to join + assist in creation and management of Congress.
    • There are many reasons for this, I’ll describe one I experienced. In months prior to congress I tried to assist with facilitation team. However their weekly meetings were in the middle of the day, on a Wednesday! This prevented me and many fellow younger folks who have jobs from participating. I pleaded with the organizers to move their meetings to weekends, but my ask was not respected, they did not move meetings to a more accessible day. To my knowledge, other congress teams were also meeting on weekdays. This would have caused accessibility issues with those teams as well. These bad organize processes prevented many from assisting the core organizing team. So, the organizers who were active were that WAY more over-stretched. Also, diversity of funding sources for funding of core organizing team + overall congress may have been less diverse than previous congresses; with at least 1 generous benefactor. I think the less diverse funding sources resulted in a core organizing team who were less accountable and were less able to meet the moment.
      • Potential Solution – By default, ALL organizing meetings should be on weekends + occasional weekday evenings. Bias of scheduling should be towards folks with jobs and/or kids, so that newer organizers (both core organizers + peripheral ones) can be brought in and trained. On the flipside, more experienced organizers MUST allow themselves to be flexible, in meeting during times which are less ideal for them. A process like this will I think naturally lead to more organizers joining in + more task delegation to occur. With more organizers present, there will be new problems (ex “too many cooks in the kitchen”). This problem can be compensated, by having more experienced facilitators to facilitate organizer teams. On a different topic, it should be a core value of future congress, that diverse income/fundraising streams, is a priority. Within income streams, grassroots support should also be prioritized.. This could result in more organizers who are more accountable and who also get more support. Organizers who are better supported can also make more thoughtful and ethical decisions.
  2. At least 1 core organizer sabotaged part of the congress through malicious, manipulative, and toxic actions.
    • These are very strong and inflammatory accusations. I expect many to vociferously disagree with my conclusion here. Please understand that I say these words with great intention and after much thought, rather than throwing them out there impulsively or reflexively. After speaking to many people, I think at least 1 core organizer was toxic and somewhat successfully manipulated the congress to forward their own agenda. I think the toxic organizer was allowed to do this, as a significant group of fellow core organizers were negligent and did NOT significantly push back on the toxic behavior; before and during congress. A sub-group of organizers DID I think push back on the toxic behavior, as best they could. However, because they only made up a small proportion of the core leadership, the toxic behavior was allowed to persist and the toxic organizer was allowed to stay in their leadership position. Ultimately, this toxic organizer was successfully called out and some power removed from them at end of congress. I don’t think this toxic person will continue in the bioregional movement BUT the conditions which could lead to a future toxic person taking over do remain I think.
      • Potential Solutions – Utilize better basic organizing techniques, so that ALL core organizers can both work together + feel comfortable calling each other on problematic behavior. This will ensure that problematic behavior will have lower chance of building over time and reaching the “toxic” behavior threshold. If toxic behavior occurs, perpetrator should be given opportunity to correct it; if it persists, perpetrator should be immediately removed from leadership. ALL core organizers should go through a consistent, transparent, vetting process. At ALL times, there should I think be a few “extra” core organizers (who are also vetted) in a congress leadership team. These “backup” organizers should be ready to jump in, if a core organizing member has to bow out or is removed. Core organizer meetings should be transparent and easily accessible. Ticket holders for future congress should be able to easily access these organizing meetings in advance of the congress. This creates outside accountability of core organizers; it’ll also make it easier to recruit volunteers for teams. Perhaps an occasional outside audit of organizing processes could create another layer of meaningful accountability.
  3. 2 core values (to me) of Bioregionalism: Communal work/connection + respect for a facilitated agenda, were not respected by the continental congress.
    • Congresses I grew up with were much more communal in their day-to-day work. For example, a meals team would organize a group of volunteers to cook + compost. This communal work created positive impacts: 2 important impacts were lowering overall cost and creating more meaningful inter-personal connections. Because this value was not prioritized, the congress occurred in a more expensive campground, where all meals + other things were taken care of by staff, rather than attendees. This increased ticket prices; this in turn was a factor for why there was only a minority of attendees who were from outside Cascadia. The less communal work also led to fewer opportunities to build camaraderie and connections; which are essential I think to activating volunteers for future congress + regional organizing. As a side-note, the campground did NOT compost and I know this was a big turn-off to many attendees; it was a violation of their morals and created more disconnect.
      • Potential Solutions – Re-integrating communal work will dramatically expand the number of organizers, volunteers, and teams. It will be helpful to review what’s worked and not worked from past continental congresses, to see what lessons will be useful here. Bioregional congresses in Mexico which are FAR MORE communal continue to this day with great success, despite fewer resources I think vs US/Canada. The techniques from these Mexican congresses should be prioritized, reviewed, and integrated as-needed. Attached Voice of the Turtle issue has article with good summary of techniques used in Mexico. Communal work should be emphasized and taught to ALL attendees well in advance of congress, so that it’s an accepted value before attendees even arrive to future congress site.
    • The core organizers generally did not follow the planned, facilitated agenda. This lead to many essential activities simply NOT happening. What I observed was that the earlier-mentioned toxic core organizer extended the timed length of ALL activity they facilitated. For example, they took control of the opening ceremony and extended it’s length to ~1/2 of the day. This prevented other organizers from implementing their respective sections of opening ceremony; they were cut. More importantly (in my opinion), it prevented the initial, planned meetups between folks from the same bioregional areas from happening. I also strongly feel that the big controversy and rupture during the congress was at least partially orchestrated behind the scenes, by the toxic core organizer. The timing of this rupture and resulting healing sessions for it, swallowed the remaining time of the continental congress. 3 critical planned events were mostly swallowed up by this hijacked time: The talking circles (where groups made up of randomly selected attendees would meetup to chat/process), the above-mentioned bioregional circles, and the topic circles (focused conversations, which would lead to creation of bioregional toolkit). These mostly-cut-out events were the events which had the most potential to create meaningful connections between folks; the connections which I feel are essential to creating momentum for a future congress. Months of prior work by so many, was wasted as those respective events did not occur. On a different topic, the lack of respect for the congress agenda in my anecdotal experience, also filtered down to workshops/group meetups which needed facilitation. At some of these, I observed that many new continental congress attendees did not respect the consensus facilitation process or the facilitators. A complaint I saw on a sticky note summarized the situation well, saying something like “this is literally event organizing malpractice”!
      • Potential Solutions – Facilitation 101 and respecting the agenda should be better explained at start of congress, with ~5min reminders to respect keeping to time + consensus at start of each day. More buffer time for spontaneously-organized meetups/workshops should be allotted; to ensure that attendees who want less structure, have the space they need (this idea is more easily done if we have a longer-lasting future congress, more on that below). Something which will also help resolve these issues, is to implement the earlier-noted solutions of reducing problematic behavior from core organizers and prevent ANY toxic behavior from organizers or attendees. Perhaps a short, daily, facilitation training at future congresses would help activate beginner facilitators + better establish healthy norms too.
  4. The congress was too short.
    • As noted earlier, the lack of cost-lowering communal work resulted in a more expensive camp. I anecdotally heard that organizers had to pay ~$89,000 to rent the camp! Whether this number is accurate or not, it’s clear that the camp was super expensive (relative to cost of living), vs. previous congress campgrounds. This high cost was to my knowledge a big reason why the continental congress was only ~4 days long (if we combine shorter starting + ending days). The shorter length of this congress had many negative consequences. Folks who could only attend a few days had fewer flexible options for which days they could attend. The compressed schedule not only ensured that less could be done, it also meant that there was less “down-time.” Down-time I think is essential for creating deeper, longer-lasting connections. Less downtime also put more pressure on attendees; which fueled negative perceptions as congress agenda was not respected. Less downtime prevented many attendees from physically exploring and connect to the natural areas of the campground and area. The resulting lack of connection to bioregion created another moral violation for many; a deep disconnect.
      • Potential Solutions – Have future congress in a much far less expensive regions than Cascadia. Less expensive areas could be in Plains bioregions, the MidWest/Great Plains of US, or areas of Mexico. Re-integration of communal work into future congress will reduce costs further. Finally, work-trade discounts should NOT be offered to future congress attendees. Organizers of congresses in Mexico (to my knowledge) also don’t offer discounts, they seem to have very successful events. There is the expectation at those Mexico events, that ALL attendees MUST contribute in some way to the day-to-day work of running that event. Communal work should be implemented, with accommodations based on disability/age, so that everyone, no matter what they can physically do, can meaningfully contribute. Implementing these changes I think will lower overall congress cost enough, so that a future congress is both cheaper, more accessible; cheap enough that a week-long event is feasible.


Daniel Lassman Restoration Ecologist

_._,_._,_

Posted in